LOCAL NEWS:

Man Tries To Rob Coffee Stand

KEYWORD:

A   A   A

Posted: Friday, 20 July 2012 4:31AM

'America's toughest' sheriff on trial over discrimination claims



PHOENIX (Reuters) - Arizona lawman Joe Arpaio, who calls himself America's toughest sheriff, was accused of racial profiling as a trial began on Thursday in a class-action lawsuit alleging he discriminated against Latinos in his crackdown on illegal immigration.

The case will test whether the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office can target those in the country illegally in immigration sweeps without racially profiling Hispanic citizens and legal residents.

The 80-year-old Arpaio, who is seeking re-election to a sixth term in November, has been a lightning rod for controversy over his aggressive enforcement of tough immigration laws in the border state with Mexico and his volunteer posse's investigation into the validity of President Barack Obama's birth certificate.

Arpaio was not in court on Thursday when lawyers for both sides in the class-action suit made opening statements before Judge Murray Snow in the non-jury bench trial at U.S. District Court in Phoenix.

"A fundamental value of our nation is equal protection under laws, regardless of race or ethnicity," plaintiff attorney Stanley Young said.

He added he would argue that Arpaio's office had "engaged in racial discrimination," and particularly cited his immigration sweeps, or "saturation patrols."

Tim Casey, a lawyer for Arpaio and the sheriff's office, said his side would prove there was no such profiling as alleged by the five plaintiffs in the lawsuit nor was there discrimination by the office in three stops cited in the suit.

"We have five plaintiffs on three stops. The evidence will show race and ethnicity had nothing to do with their traffic stops," he said.

The trial focuses attention again on Arizona, which claimed headlines last month when the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a key element of the state's crackdown on illegal immigrants requiring police to investigate those they stop and suspect of being in the country illegally.

Supporters said the law was needed because the U.S. federal government had failed to secure the porous Southwest border with Mexico. Obama's administration challenged it in court, saying the U.S. Constitution gives the federal government sole authority over immigration policy.

Arpaio faces a separate, broader lawsuit lodged by the U.S. Justice Department in May, alleging systematic profiling, sloppy and indifferent police work and a disregard for minority rights by him and county officials.

Protesters from both sides of the debate gathered outside the court from early morning toting flags and placards. One read, "Sheriff Joe does immigration sweeps, makes drug busts, what more do you want?"

"No to hate, no to fear" and "God forgive Arpaio," read others.

EXPERT WITNESS

Lawyers for the plaintiffs called Ralph Taylor, a criminal justice expert at Temple University in Philadelphia, who analyzed racial and ethnic patterns from traffic stops carried out by the office from 2007 to 2009, including about a dozen "saturation patrols" in the Phoenix valley.

Taylor told the court that when an officer ran a name check on the day of a major sweep, there was "a much higher likelihood" the name run would be Hispanic than non-Hispanic. He also testified that when an officer ran a check of at least one Hispanic name, the stop would take about two minutes longer.

During cross-examination, the defense called Taylor's study biased, arguing it failed to take into account variables including language difficulties that might lengthen stops involving Hispanics, and did not draw on complete data sets.

David Vasquez, 47, testified he was stopped by sheriff's officers in June 2008 during a sweep, ostensibly because he had a cracked windshield. The officer asked Vasquez if he spoke English and checked his driver's license and other documents, but did not cite him.

"I just found it funny that he asked me if I spoke English ... because I felt that I was being singled out," Vasquez said in testifying for the plaintiffs, adding he later told his wife he believed he was "pulled over for ‘driving while brown.'"

The five plaintiffs in the suit are Hispanics stopped by deputies and the Somos America immigrants' rights coalition. It was later expanded to include all Latino drivers stopped by the office since 2007.

The lawsuit was brought in the name of Mexican tourist Manuel Ortega Melendres, who was a passenger in a vehicle pulled over by deputies in 2007, ostensibly for speeding. Melendres was arrested, despite having a valid visa and producing identification, while the vehicle's white driver was neither cited nor taken into custody.

The defense counsel asked the deputy who stopped the vehicle, Louis DiPietro, if he relied on skin color in a decision to detain anyone, to which he replied, "No."

Story & Photos Copyright 2012 Reuters

Yahoo buying Tumblr for $1.1 billion


Yahoo said it is buying blogging service Tumblr for $1.1 billion cash.

Winning $590.5 million Powerball lottery ticket sold in Florida


A single winning ticket for a record Powerball lottery jackpot was sold in Florida.

Powerful tornadoes strike in four central states


A massive storm front swept north through the central United States.

VIDEO: Meteoroid impact triggers bright flash on the moon


An automated telescope monitoring the moon captured images of a meteoroid impact. Watch!

House lawmakers reach deal to revamp immigration


Prospects for passage of a major immigration bill has improved.

House votes to repeal Obamacare for 37th time


The Republican-controlled U.S. House voted to repeal Obamacare in a symbolic move.

Judge to hear insanity defense in theater shooting case


The judge who will hear the murder case against accused James Holmes has agreed to hear arguments.

Boston bombing suspect wrote message in boat


Accused Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev left a handwritten message.

Tornadoes rip through Texas, killing six


At least six people were killed when tornadoes ripped through a stretch of Texas.

As scandals mount, White House springs into damage control


With no sign of an end to three scandals, the White House launched a concerted effort at damage control.

Tax chief forced out in IRS scandal


Steven Miller resigned as the acting head of the Internal Revenue Service.

White House releases Benghazi attack emails


The White House released 100 pages of emails detailing discussion about deadly attacks in Benghazi.

Holder sidesteps lawmakers' questions on AP records seizure


Lawmakers pounded Attorney General Eric Holder with questions.

Accused Cleveland kidnapper plans to plead not guilty


The man charged with holding three women captive and raping them will plead not guilty.

Once a beacon, Obama under fire over civil liberties


Barack Obama has faced accusation after accusation of impinging on civil liberties.